States foreshadow legal battle over Trump’s Tongass rule
Originally published in E&E news by Marc Heller on December 17, 2019
Attorneys general in six states urged the Trump administration yesterday to withdraw a proposal to open more of Alaska’s Tongass National Forest to logging, saying it violates several aspects of federal law.
None of the administration’s alternatives that would scale back the 2001 Roadless Area Conservation Rule in the Tongass are lawful, said the officials, representing California, Illinois, Massachusetts, New York, Oregon and Washington state in a letter to the Forest Service that could telegraph future legal action.
“The undersigned States therefore urge the Forest Service to correct these fundamental legal defects or withdraw the Proposed Rule,” they said.
In their letter, submitted in advance of today’s deadline for public comments on the proposal, the officials criticized the administration for ignoring potential environmental impacts such as effects on carbon sequestration and climate change, and for inadequately consulting with the Fish and Wildlife Service and NOAA Fisheries.
The proposal, they said, doesn’t rationally explain a change in policy and violates the Administrative Procedure Act, National Environmental Policy Act and Endangered Species Act.
At issue is the administration’s move to exempt the nearly 17-million-acre Tongass from the roadless rule, which prevents the construction of roads and logging and other activities, although the Forest Service has granted some exceptions. The Department of Agriculture, which oversees the Forest Service, said its preferred alternative is a total exemption, which would free 9.2 million acres from the rule, although officials say only 185,000 acres would be newly deemed suitable for timber harvesting.
Less-restrictive regulations wouldn’t necessarily generate more timber harvests, the Forest Service has said, but would give forest managers more flexibility in where to cut down trees. That could lead to more cost-effective timber production, officials say. Other economic activity in southeastern Alaska, such as mining and hydropower, could benefit as well through a less-cumbersome approvals process, supporters say.
Alaska officials on both the state and federal level have sought a full exemption, saying the region’s economic reliance on the Tongass makes it different from other national forests. Timber industry groups and economic development agencies support an exemption.
Opposing an exemption are tribal governments, recreation groups and commercial fishing operations that say they worry about impacts on salmon.
Critics cite the forest’s role in sequestering carbon. Researchers with the Geos Institute and the University of Colorado, Denver, said the Forest Service underestimates the amount of carbon stored in old-growth forests, which haven’t been logged.
The carbon stored in Tongass roadless areas may be worth as much as $234 million to $2.2 billion, depending on offset markets and the amount of logging in the next 100 years, said the researchers, Dominick DellaSala of the Geos Institute and Brian Buma, an assistant professor at the University of Colorado.
They noted Sealaska Corp.’s active role in carbon markets, including the sale of more than $100 million in carbon offset credits to help BP PLC offset carbon emissions; Sealaska, an Alaska Native corporation active in timber and other industries in southeastern Alaska, supports a roadless-rule exemption as an economic development measure that could benefit tribal communities.
Other alternatives USDA is considering would exempt portions of the forest or leave the roadless-area protections fully in place. Officials say they’ll make a final decision next June and that public comments — which have been overwhelmingly negative — will be taken into account.
The attorneys general said the Forest Service appears to have abandoned its own earlier justifications for limiting road construction.
“The Service now asserts that a Tongass exemption is justified because roadless area management in Southeast Alaska is controversial, and it is therefore preferable to decide the fate of roadless areas on a case-by-case basis,” they said. “This reasoning ignores that the Service found the opposite in adopting the 2001 Roadless Rule, concluding that national protection for roadless areas was necessary to avoid the cost and litigation of case-by-case decisionmaking.”
Email: mheller@eenews.net
Join the Cornerstone Network
Sign up with a monthly donation and become part of our Cornerstone Network. Network members recieve the messages posted here first, delivered directly to your inbox. Your ongoing support is the foundation of our work.
Arsum is the Senior Adaptation and Coastal Resilience Specialist for the National Wildlife Federation’s Southcentral Region. In this role, she advances climate adaptation efforts, with a focus on nature-based approaches to address the impacts of climate change and extreme events across the Gulf region. She has authored and co-authored numerous publications on climate impact assessments and adaptation solutions. Additionally, she regularly participates in state-based coastal resilience and hazard mitigation planning across the Gulf, collaborating with regional and local stakeholders.
Frank is the former President of the Reinsurance Association of America. Frank currently serves on the Advisory Board of the OECD’s International Network for the Financial Management of Large-Scale Disasters, the RAND Center on Catastrophic Risk Management and Compensation, and the University of Cincinnati’s Carl H. Lindner III Center for Insurance and Risk Management Advisory Board.
Jim is a multilingual world traveler. Based in Bavaria during the 1970s, Jim spent most of this period in India, Afghanistan and Nepal, where he founded and operated a charitable medical clinic serving Tibetan Refugees. He settled in Oregon in 1983 on a forested ranch in the Umpqua National Forest.
Dr. Micah Hahn is an Associate Professor of Environmental Health in the Institute for Circumpolar Health Studies at the University of Alaska-Anchorage. She received her joint PhD in Epidemiology / Environment and Resources from the University of Wisconsin-Madison and her MPH in Global Environmental Health from Emory University. Subsequently, she was a postdoctoral fellow for the CDC Climate and Health Program, and in this position worked collaboratively with the CDC Division of Vector-borne Diseases and the National Center for Atmospheric Research. Her research focuses on understanding the health impacts of climate change and working with communities to develop locally-relevant adaptation and resilience-building strategies. Dr. Hahn is also on the Management Team of the Alaska Climate Adaptation Science Center.
Michael is a former Founding Principal of Resilient Cities Catalyst, a global non-profit helping cities and their partners tackle their toughest challenges. He is currently the Executive Director of Climate Resilience Academy at the University of Miami.
Dr. Quintus Jett is a consultant, educator, and strategist for public causes. He has a doctorate in Organizations & Management from Stanford University, and a two-decade faculty career which spans schools, departments, and programs of business, engineering, liberal studies, divinity, and public and nonprofit management. Following Hurricane Katrina in 2005, Dr. Jett launched a volunteer project in New Orleans, which enlisted residents, students from over a dozen colleges and universities, and hundreds of others to field map the city’s Gentilly district, Lower Ninth Ward, and New Orleans East. Dr. Jett is an innovator in higher education, bridging the divide between academic research and the other priorities of the modern university, including student access and diversity, community engagement, and providing foundations for life-long learning in today’s rapidly changing world.
Scott is Monfort Professor of Atmospheric Science at Colorado State University. He has written about 100 publications in the peer-reviewed climate literature, is a former editor of the Journal of Climate, and served for five years as founding Science Chair of the North American Carbon Program.
Linda has many years of experience in disaster preparedness and resilience. She has been an elected official on the Linn County Iowa Board of Supervisors, Chair of the Metropolitan Planning Organization, the East Central Iowa Council of Governments, the statewide Mental Health Developmental Disability and the Linn County Board of Health. Langston is a former president of the National Association of Counties (2013-2014).
Ken works with families and organizations as a mediator, organizational consultant, trainer and facilitator. Along with his passion for helping people prepare for and reduce climate change, Ken also volunteers as a mediator through Mediation Works and is passionate about supporting youth through mentoring with Boys to Men of Southern Oregon.
Matthew is a retired high school teacher who was once honored as Oregon High School Social Studies Teacher of the Year. Before his teaching career he was in the restaurant business in Portland. He is also a lawyer who has been a member of the Oregon State Bar Association since 1980.
Andrea is the Resilience Policy Advisor for the North Carolina Office of Recovery and Resiliency. She works across state agencies and with local governments to increase the state’s resilience to the impacts of climate change.